It took me to the edge: one kid is enough

I made this drawing a few days after R was born. I wanted to capture a profound moment of being seen and understood- the neonatal nurse’s simple statement of acknowledgement, ‘it pushed you to the edge of what you were capable of,’ when she found me fighting back tears, attempting to feed my newborn son on the maternity ward. Something about her manner released something I didn’t know I was keeping inside and my whole birth story had come pouring out of my mouth as she held R. I’d been trying to hold myself together and contain all the fear and shock of birth in my usual avoidant, mutant way. Her words gave me permission to own what I could barely admit to myself: I have an edge, and all those contractions and pushing for all those hours brought me to some paradoxically sacred-profane threshold of euphoria and pain. It was almost unbearable. Something as ordinary as birth could have undone me- I might not have been able to assimilate so much suffering into my personality and use it for my own growth. That I endured the pain and was able to symbolise it to myself afterwards is a miracle. I wrestled with a bear and came back revenant-style, over the horizon on a white horse.

The edge is a risky place to go- it is necessary for me to mark it and stay well away from it most of the time. Its great for rites of passage and initiations into new lives and identities, but a terrible place to set up house. I’ve been here, in varying distances from it, for three years. It’s time for me to start packing. Some people are great in a crisis. I am not someone who thrives on adrenal thrills and frenetic, overstretched living. The edge is a sacred-profane place I go to be transformed, but then I must retreat.

I recently decided to give away all of Rs baby things in recognition of my limits. I’ve been storing his old babygrows in the loft for ‘the second one.’ Other people choose to have two or three kids, I am not other people. Growing a baby inside me and pushing him out and doing parenting has been one of the most intense and weird and glorious experiences of my life and I’ve become all kinds of strong and deep and found parts of my soul I didn’t know existed.

But I’m ready to grow different parts of myself and learn new stuff about me now.

I don’t have another kid in me unless I sacrifice more of my psyche and soma than I’m willing to relinquish. It has been a relief to admit this to myself, to fold the washed sleepsuits into plastic carrier sacs and give away the fantasy of the second child, one bag at a time. A second kid would make me stay here, on the cusp of what I’m capable of, the knife-edge of nearly too much.

The resources a child absorbs – psychic, economic, environmental, relational- are enormous. How many women go mad with motherhood and lose themselves in the welter of care giving? I made a list, spanning early pregnancy to toddlerhood, of what, both in body and in soul, has been necessary to give up or risk or ration to make room for my son’s emergent subjectivity – I want to welcome many of these things back in, gradually, as R becomes more independent and needs me less. To make it clear, I chose to have a kid, and I have willingly entered into this adventure. This list is not laced with threats of guilt tripping or martyrdom. Living on the edge has been fruitful for me too. I guess this list honours the shape of my identity, it is a way to beat the bounds and mark where I start and finish. These are the pleasures that make me, me (I’m very aware other parents probably have different lists!) and when I have to make do without them for too long I’m in danger of not turning up to my own life and living for someone else.

Booze, stinky cheese, cigars


Being not-needed


Really deep chat, the kind that is sprawling and investigative and leaves your soul glowing with satisfaction. The kind you need several afternoon hours alone with a good friend or a whole weekend and lots of whisky to do properly.

Uninterrupted conversations

Leaving the house without too much thought or preparation

The meanings of my non-maternal body

My body belonging to me, not sharing it with another human first for nine months then for the duration of the breastfeeding relationship

An un-colonised mind. Falling in love with a tiny human obliterates other kinds of thinking

The risk of prolapse (estimated to be 1 in 3 women) I escaped this tragedy last pregnancy and birth, but there are no guarantees and every pregnancy puts an strain on the pelvic floor muscles. We rarely talk about this issue

Leisurely application of eyeliner and lipstick

Showers either alone or without someone shouting with strong, emotive expression outside the door that they wish you were not having a shower alone

Ditto with the toilet

Time to think

Time to lie on the sofa and just be

A reasonable amount of washing

The risk of birth injuries. I broke my tailbone pushing

The risk of postpartum depression and PTSD after a difficult birth

Fitting into all my lovely clothing

A martial relationship without the inevitable strain exhaustion, bewilderment, in depth discussions about purée and overdraft use puts on it


Walking the city

Money from two incomes

Time to myself

Effortless emotional equilibrium

Normal sleep and wake patterns that don’t involve being woken at 2am or falling asleep at 6pm

Time for reading or writing or creative life

My internal attention focused exclusively on me instead of being locked into vigil and keeping-in-mind

Late nights

Energy to watch a film


Doing things on a whim


Abundant solitude

Copyright Diana Smith 2018

6 thoughts on “It took me to the edge: one kid is enough”

  1. Hi,

    I just wanted to let you know how much your writing means to me. You are able to enunciate so many things about motherhood in a way that I couldn’t. Your strength in naming obstacles and emotions is helping me do the same. I am also reading Mindsight because of you. Motherhood demands so much of yourself, but also provides daily joy in the struggle. I too yearn for more time alone with my thoughts and the ability to aimlessly wander. That was my walking meditation and it is gone now. Anyway, thank you for bravely sharing your thoughts in an educated manner that this fellow scientist understands.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Michelle, thank you so much for such a generous and thoughtful response. I’m so glad you’re enjoying my writing and I totally agree with your words about motherhood being ‘a daily joy and struggle’ and thanks for sharing your own loss of walking meditation. Motherhood is such a big ask.


  2. Thank you! This articulated how I feel and have been struggling to define in myself. I have slowly come to the realisation I have had one beautiful child and that is good for me. And it is OK.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Hi Michelle, so glad this helped! I think the hard question so often is ‘how should I live?’ and often the answer is surprising and looks different from person to person. So glad this helped you feel ok about your decision. ‘One beautiful child’ as you say is definitely enough.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s